Procurement guides

How to Verify Reference Installations When Shortlisting a PEM Electrolyzer Supplier

Define what makes an installation comparable before asking suppliers for references.

Table of Contents

Define what makes an installation comparable before asking suppliers for references. For a complete proton exchange membrane (PEM) electrolyzer system, compare the application, rating basis, commissioned configuration and the part of the delivery the bidder actually performed. Require evidence for the criteria that govern the shortlist and identify any gap that needs clarification.

Convert the scope of the purchase into reference criteria

Start with the intended use and what the supplier will deliver. A research platform, a packaged hydrogen system and a stack supplied to an integrator can involve different responsibilities. List the functions that need to appear in the reference and the ones the buyer will assess separately. For each installation, record the technology, intended use, commissioned date, reference rating and the basis of that rating.

An RWTH Aachen University procurement notice provides an example. The purchase calls for an operable modular PEM system with a 45 kW nominal electrical rating for electrolysis. The qualification criteria request three comparable installations commissioned within the preceding three years. They also specify a nominal rating range for the complete reference system and require the reference to include water treatment, electrolysis stacks and hydrogen purification. Those criteria apply to that procurement. Use the approved requirements of your own order to set any count, date window and equipment boundary. RWTH Aachen procurement conditions, North Rhine-Westphalia procurement portal

For a like-for-like comparison, ask what the reference power figure measures. The rating for electrolysis and the rating for the complete reference system may describe different scopes. Keep the description alongside each value instead of assuming the same basis from a shared unit.

Verify the installation and the supplier's role

Ask for evidence that establishes the event your criteria specify. A purchase order can document scope. A dated commissioning or acceptance record can support the corresponding milestone if it identifies the installation and the configuration. Where the procurement requires customer verification, use a contact route authorized for that disclosure and keep personal information within the permitted process.

Check who owned the work. A supplier may have furnished a stack while an integrator supplied the controls, water treatment and purification. Ask for a scope statement that identifies each party's delivery and commissioning responsibilities. If a subcontractor or partner is named as the source of experience, ask procurement which attribution the qualification rules allow and what involvement must be documented.

Use one row per installation, including its source, verification status and the assessment against each criterion. If a supplier offers a relevant case with a different configuration, describe what the case demonstrates and leave the uncovered element open for review. Apply the same criteria across bids.

Anonymous reference cards for commissioned date, rating basis and supplier role feed a comparison of scope, evidence and open questions.
Conceptual reference-review worksheet with blank fields. The cards represent no actual installations or supplier achievements; reference requirements are defined for each purchase.

Anonymous reference cards for commissioned date, rating basis and supplier role feed a comparison of scope, evidence and open questions. Conceptual reference-review worksheet with blank fields. The cards represent no actual installations or supplier achievements; reference requirements are defined for each purchase.

Keep experience, expected life and warranty separate

Record any expected life figure with its scope and basis. The Aachen notice asks for expected life as a reference field. To understand the figure, ask what component or system it describes, which duty assumptions were used and what end condition defines the estimate. Where the buyer also wants operating evidence, request the period actually observed, any relevant replacements and the source of the record. A recent installation can demonstrate commissioning while offering limited operating history.

Review the warranty for the proposed equipment as a separate contractual item. Identify its start, duration, covered items, conditions and remedies. A record from another installation may help assess experience. The proposed contract determines what the supplier is offering for this purchase.

Before selecting a shortlist, ask engineering to confirm technical comparability and procurement to record missing evidence or authorized clarifications. For a project enquiry, share the intended system boundary, application, rating basis and the reference criteria used by your team. Ask which evidence can be provided for the proposed scope and through which authorized route. HELE PEM electrolyzer enquiries

Frequently asked questions

Can an installation count if it was delivered but has not started operating?

Use the milestone named in the qualification criteria. If they require commissioning, ask for a dated record or authorized confirmation of commissioning before considering that criterion met.

Can a larger system serve as a comparable reference?

It depends on the approved rating range and scope. Ask how the reference rating was defined and whether the functions relevant to the new purchase are documented. Record the scale difference for the reviewer.

How should a reference built by a partner be presented?

Identify the partner, the bidder's own work and the role each would have in the proposed supply. Verify eligibility under the procurement rules and ask for documentation of the relevant responsibilities.

What if the customer cannot be named during an initial review?

Determine whether the buyer permits redacted evidence, confidential access or later verification. An anonymized description can support a preliminary discussion where allowed. Keep any required verification outstanding until it is resolved.

Can commissioning and operating hours be recorded in the same field?

Use separate fields. A commissioning date identifies a milestone. Operating hours need a defined observation period and source, and may exclude downtime. Request the record that matches the decision.

Can a reference warranty be used to compare current bids?

Ask each bidder for the warranty offered on the quoted configuration. Compare covered equipment and remedies under the actual proposals. A previous contract may contain different terms.

Prepare a technical enquiry

Share the hydrogen or test duty, operating conditions, interfaces and the equipment scope you need reviewed.

Ask a technical question →

References

About the publisher

HELE Titanium

HELE Titanium supports industrial buyers with titanium materials, electrochemical anodes and PEM system project review.

Meet the HELE team →

WhatsApp